Mandatory Military Service: A High School Perspective
Jake, a high school sophomore, finds himself in a debate with his classmates about mandatory military service. Some argue that it fosters discipline and unity, while others view it as an infringement upon freedom. Jake begins wondering about countries like Israel and South Korea, where military service is compulsory. In South Korea, each male citizen must serve for nearly two years. They view this as a necessity to protect their country from potential threats, given their geopolitical location. On the other hand, Israel follows a policy of universal conscription for both men and women, which they believe contributes to their national security and social cohesion. As Jake ponders, he realizes that while mandatory service can instill discipline and encourage citizenship, it also implies a significant commitment that not everyone may be prepared for. He reflects on the impact it can have on an individual's life choices, career direction, and personal freedom. Jake concludes that the topic of mandatory military service is more complex than he initially thought. Encouraged by his newfound understanding, he decides to continue exploring other perspectives and encourages his classmates to do the same.
Question 1
What is the main argument against mandatory military service, as considered by Jake?
It fosters discipline
It is necessary for national security
It infringes upon personal freedom
It encourages citizenship
It results in social cohesion
Question 2
Why does South Korea enforce mandatory military service on all of its male citizens?
To increase employment rates
To encourage social cohesion
To protect the country from potential threats
To promote physical fitness
To prepare for potential invasions from extraterrestrial life
Question 3
What is unique about Israel's conscription policy compared to that of South Korea's?
Israel only requires military service from men
Israel requires military service from both men and women
Israel does not require mandatory military service
Israel requires a shorter period of service
Israel's service is primarily focused on combat training
Question 4
How does Jake's understanding of the topic evolve?
He becomes more confused
He agrees entirely with his classmates' perspectives
He decides that mandatory military service is unnecessary
He realizes the complexity of the topic and decides to explore more perspectives
He decides to enlist in the military
Question 5
What is the term for compulsory military service?
Exemption
Enlistment
Conservation
Conscription
Conscription
or share via
Assign the ReadTheory pretest to determine students' reading levels.
